Does the Soul Exist? Jewish Answers on Consciousness, Free Will, and Life After Death

Oded asks: “Hello, what proof is there that a person really has a soul that continues on after 120 years? Also, if God wants what is good for man, why does He create babies with defects?

I’ve always heard that humans are different from animals only because the human brain is more developed, and that consciousness and free will are located in the brain. Is there any clear evidence for life after death? I’ve also heard that during clinical death the brain generates visions from the subconscious. And as for ideas like morality and justice, we see that these exist among non-Jews as well.”

* * *

Hello Oded,

There are many proofs for the existence of the soul. To see them, we need to use reason. I’ll first present the proofs, and afterwards we can consider whether they could be explained as merely coming from the brain.

1. Consciousness and Free Will

Logical proofs show that a human being is different from all animals and has inner faculties that cannot be explained by nature, such as free will and self-awareness. These have no place in the purely physical world. The laws of nature do not allow for the concept of choosing between good and evil — animals act by instinct alone. The very existence of an autonomous will in humans points to a spiritual essence inside, which continues to exist even after the body dies. In science this is referred to as “the mind–body problem.”

2. Love, Justice, and Mercy

Humans experience concepts that have no material basis. Love, compassion, morality, conscience, justice, and values have no physical particles or molecules, yet people consider them more important than anything else in life. This points to the spiritual source within man. Regarding your question about non-Jews, morality was implanted by the Creator in all people. Abraham himself sought God and was righteous even before the Torah was given. However, with the Torah we know precisely how to carry out God’s will by choosing good, avoiding evil, and connecting to Him. The Torah is the “manufacturer’s manual”.

3. The Struggle with the Evil Inclination

The very existence of both a good and evil inclination within us shows that we are being tested for our deeds, which is clear evidence of accountability after death.

4. Innate Knowledge of Eternity

There has never been a culture on earth that did not reach the conclusion that humans have souls and that life continues after death. This universal awareness shows that it is deeply embedded within human nature.

5. Dissatisfaction with Material Life

Animals are satisfied with food, reproduction, and survival. Humans, by contrast, are never content with material life alone, no matter how much wealth, food, or comfort they have. This shows that a spiritual soul lives within, yearning for its Creator.

6. The Religious Drive

Humans everywhere feel a powerful spiritual instinct to seek their Creator, to pray, to worship. This is universal, crossing all cultures and ages. Such a drive cannot come from material instincts, but from the soul itself, whose mission is to connect with its Source.

If humans were only material, they would be content with material pleasures. The fact that they reach for meaning, truth, and transcendence, proves the spiritual root inside them.

7. Testimonies of Life After Death

There are millions of reports of near-death experiences across all cultures. People describe leaving their bodies and experiencing heightened clarity while their brain and heart had stopped. They consistently report seeing “a gate” to the next world. The claim that these are only imagined hallucinations is false, as most reports across cultures describe the same core experience.

On Birth Defects

Congenital defects are related to spiritual causes from before the soul’s birth. Sometimes they serve a specific mission, while other times they are correction or atonement for wrongs committed in previous lives.

Could the Brain Be the Source?

The brain is a machine — a sophisticated computer. Where does consciousness come from? Even the most advanced computer will never spontaneously develop independent thought, curiosity, or moral conscience. It only executes code.

The brain, too, cannot explain free will, conscience, or the search for God. These are not material phenomena. The very fact that humans experience them shows there is a soul operating through the brain. When the body dies, the soul returns to its Creator.