Pain-Free Kosher Slaughter: The Torah Laws of Shechitah

The Torah’s laws on preparing meat are not merely technical requirements. They reflect a profound respect for life and spiritual refinement, even as we make use of animals for food.

This article explores two central mitzvot: shechitah (ritual slaughter) and kisuy hadam (covering the blood).

The Mitzvah of Shechitah (Ritual Slaughter)

The Torah requires that anyone who wishes to eat meat from poultry (off), wild animals (chayah), or domesticated animals (beheimah) must first perform shechitah—ritual slaughter according to halachah (Jewish law).

The knife used must be extremely sharp and completely smooth, with no nicks or flaws, and must be checked before each animal is slaughtered. In the Sefer HaChinuch (a comprehensive guide to the mitzvot and the reasons behind them), this is explained by the need to minimize the pain experienced by the animal:

“... it is well-known that the body’s blood emerges from the neck more than from other parts of the body, [therefore] we were commanded to slaughter from there before we eat it. In this way all its blood will come out, and we will ‘not eat the soul with the flesh.’

“We can also say as a reason for slaughter from the neck with a checked knife, that it is in order that we not cause too much pain to living beings. The Torah only permitted man — due to his status — to derive nourishment from them for all his needs, but not to cause them pain for no reason.”

The Sefer HaChinuch was authored in the thirteenth century CE, before studies were made comparing slaughter methods. In our days, renowned animal experts such as Dr. Temple Grandin have affirmed that shechitah is the most humane method of killing animals, with the animal losing consciousness within just two seconds.

Shechitah is thus designed not only to make meat kosher, but also to cultivate sensitivity and humility, reminding us that even necessary killing should be done with compassion and respect.

The Mitzvah of Covering the Blood

This mitzvah applies specifically to poultry (off) and wild animals (chayah). After slaughtering these animals, the Torah commands us to cover their spilled blood with earth, as is stated in Vayikra (Leviticus 17:13):

“Any Israelite or stranger living among them who hunts a wild animal or bird that may be eaten shall pour out its blood and cover it with earth.”

How is the mitzvah performed?

• Before shechitah, earth is placed on the ground where the blood will fall.

• After shechitah, the blood is covered with more earth so that there is earth beneath and above the blood.

• The Talmud (Chullin 83b) derives this from the phrase “cover it with earth,” teaching that the blood must be completely enveloped.

The Blessing:
Before covering the blood, one recites:

“Baruch Atah Hashem Elokeinu Melech HaOlam Asher Kidshanu Be’mitzvotav Ve’tzivanu Al Kisuy Hadam Ba’afar—Blessed are You, Lord our God, King of the Universe, who sanctified us with His commandments and commanded us to cover the blood with earth.”

Who performs this mitzvah?

• The obligation rests primarily on the shochet (the ritual slaughterer).

• If the owner of the animal wishes to fulfill the mitzvah, he or she should first ask permission from the shochet.

According to the Sefer HaChinuch, one of the reasons why we cover the blood is because the spirit of the animal is contained in its blood (which is also why we kasher meat by salting, to remove the blood):

“It is from the roots of the commandment that the soul is dependent upon the blood ... Therefore it is fitting for us to cover the soul and hide it from the eyes of those who see it before we eat the meat. For we acquire a bit of cruelty in our souls when we eat the meat, while the soul is spilled in front of us.”

This mitzvah teaches us to confront the reality of taking life and to temper it with compassion.

Forbidden Meat from Kosher Animals

Shechitah is not just a permissible way of killing an animal for food—it is the only way to obtain meat for food. Animals which die not via shechitah are not permitted for consumption.

• A neveilah is an animal which died on its own, and it may not be eaten.
• If shechitah was performed but was found to be invalid (e.g., the knife was found afterward to have a nick), the animal is also declared a neveilah and may not be eaten.
• A treifah is an animal that had an illness or injury that would have led to its death within 12 months. Even if undergoes shechitah, it remains prohibited for consumption.
• This is why animals are carefully inspected after shechitah, to check for a variety of health issues.
• An animal found, after valid shechitah, to have a puncture or hole in the lung or another vital organ is declared a treifah in almost all cases.

Force-Fed Geese and the Problem of Foie Gras

Particularly in previous generations (less so today), geese were often force-fed to enlarge their livers  (producing foie gras).

How Force-Feeding Works

• When geese reach around 9 lbs (their natural weight), they are force-fed three times daily.

• A machine pushes about a pound of cooked corn down their throats using a long tube inserted deep into the esophagus.

• This process continues for about three weeks until the geese reach nearly 18 lbs in weight.

• They are then slaughtered immediately, as they cannot survive much longer in such a state.

​

Halachic Concerns with Force-Fed Geese

Tza’ar Ba’alei Chayim (Animal Suffering):

• Force-feeding causes clear pain and distress and it is forbidden to do so for no valid reason (and producing a delicacy is not considered a valid reason).

Treifah Concerns:

• Force-feeding can cause injuries such as tears or punctures in the esophagus.

• Even with softer feed and thinner tubes, injuries remain common.

• Critically, the birds are so weakened they would not survive 12 months, classifying them as treifah.

Therefore, foie gras should not be eaten.

The Torah’s commandments of shechitah and kisuy hadam are not simply ritual details. They are designed to instill compassion, humility, and respect for life—even as we use animals for food.

By understanding these mitzvot and applying their principles we honor the Torah’s vision of a refined and conscientious Jewish life.